Showing posts with label community choice act. Show all posts
Showing posts with label community choice act. Show all posts

Tuesday, August 25, 2009

Disability and Health Care Reform: A Firsthand Perspective


Writing in the Huffington Post, Ari Ne'eman, head of the Autism Self-Advocacy Network, outlines a number of issues that need to be addressed to ensure that health care reform does not leave behind adults and children with disabilities. I always appreciate Ari's passion and insights. Following is a summary of his key points.

Long Term Services and Supports
To get Medicaid support for basic services they need to survive, many people must live in nursing homes and institutions. "Both research and the experience of countless people with disabilities show that, with the right support, people can live in the community rather than be relegated to institutions. Community living settings, when properly implemented, improve quality of life, reduce the risk of abuse, make it more likely that a person with a disability will be able to work and are actually much less costly than institutional care....Medicaid's long-term care policy reimburses states for costly and segregated institutional care but makes it extraordinary difficult to use the same money to support adults in the community instead. A person who uses a wheelchair or an adult with a developmental disability such as autism or Down Syndrome can get the government to pay for a costly institutional placement with low quality of life, but often must spend years on a waiting list for far less expensive services, such as attendant care that could keep them in their home or their family's...."

"President Obama won kudos from the disability community by supporting the Community Choice Act during his campaign, but since then the White House has signaled that this issue will not be considered as part of health care reform. The Community Choice Act should be properly considered a civil rights issue, as it means the difference between segregation or integration for millions of disabled citizens as well as many senior citizens."

Health Care Disparities for People with Disabilities
"Too often, medical problems faced by people with disabilities are assumed to be normal and unavoidable as a result of being disabled. However, disability and ill health should not be considered synonymous. People with disabilities face significant barriers to access quality health care, due to both poverty and accessibility problems....Congress must recognize people with disabilities as an underserved population subject to health disparities by undertaking both data collection and serious policy reform to ensure that issues of access, expertise and coverage are address for the disability community."

Insurance Discrimination
While some states are addressing reform to mandate insurance coverage for autism and other disabilities, these efforts do nor represent comprehensive reform. Any health care reform must ensure insurance coverage for pre-existing conditions, including developmental disabilities.

Stop Discrimination in the Provision of Care
"Too often, people with disabilities are denied necessary -- sometimes even life-saving -- medical care because of assumptions that non-disabled people make about our quality of life. For many people, disability is still considered a fate worse than death instead of a part of the human experience. The eugenic impulse that views people with disabilities as 'burdens on society' or 'life unworthy of life' is still regrettably alive and well within our health care system....Americans, with or without disabilities, deserve not to be pitted against each other in their efforts to obtain the health care services they need. With limited resources, Congress will need to make difficult decisions -- yet discriminating against people with disabilities in the provision of health care services should never be considered an acceptable option."

Ari concludes: "Disability has often been called the great equalizer -- our community reaches throughout every racial, religious, gender and political classification. Furthermore, though we are wide and varied, including both people with acquired disabilities, such as many of our brave men and women in uniform coming home from overseas, and others who were born with their disabilities, such as myself and the rest of the autistic community, we can unite around our common dream for full participation, inclusion, integration, and equality of opportunity for all."

Read more.

Wednesday, May 20, 2009

Administration Backing Away from Support for Community Choice Act?


After the 2008 presidential campaign, I told you that I would be honest in my critique of the new administration -- giving credit when it's due but also holding the administration accountable. And I'm concerned the White House is backing away from a campaign pledge to support the Community Choice Act. In this post from Sept. 22, 2008, I criticized Sen. McCain for not supporting the Community Choice Act and pointed out that then-Sens. Obama and Biden were co-sponsors.

Medicaid requires states to cover long-term care in insitutions, but does not require states to support people who live in their own homes -- which essentially means government policy favors institutionalization over providing options that allow for more independence.

Disability advocate Michael Volkman, in a May 15 op-ed titled "Give Disabled Choice of Home," explains: "Twenty-seven states provide no community-based assistance, so people like me living in those states are taken from their families and shut away. Many other states restrict services and have long waiting lists to get them. There are people who could live independently with just a few hours of aide service each day for less than $100, and others who need more hours but still could live independently. Instead, they are forced into nursing homes at a cost of hundreds of dollars more for each person for each day."

The bills that make up the Community Choice Act, HR 1670 and S 683, have languished in Congress with little action for 12 years, so disability advocates were encouraged when the Obama-Biden campaign committed to push for its passage. But in a recent meeting with American Disabled For Attended Programs Today (ADAPT), Nancy-Ann DeParle, the administration's health care reform czar, apparently suggested the Community Choice Act might not be part of the health care reform package.

And the White House has changed the disabilities page on its website, removing President Obama's intention to enforce the Community Choice Act. Instead, a new paragraph says, "The President believes that more can be done to encourage states to shift more of their services away from institutions and into the community, which is both cost-effective and humane."

Volkman: "Encouraging states to take the lead doesn't mean they will. If they wanted to, they could have done it years ago."

Here's more from Patricia Bauer's Disability News.

Monday, September 22, 2008

Baltimore Sun: "Friendship Isn't Enough"


In an op-ed titled "Friendship Isn't Enough," the Baltimore Sun's editors say, "What do families of children with disabilities need from the next president? Not just a 'friend' in the White House but a willingness to pay for services they need."

The op-ed points out that the proposed Community Choice Act would require all states and the federal government to make such services for disabled American more widely available. While Sen. McCain doesn't support the bill, Sen. Obama is a co-sponsor. It continues:

"There are any number of other government programs that are desperately in need of help from a friend in the White House. Special education is supposed to receive 40 percent federal financing and now gets closer to 17 percent. Personal care service providers, who are vital to keeping disabled people living independently, are chronically underpaid and, because of that, difficult to find and retain. The candidates' views on these matters are reflected on their websites. Mr. Obama's includes a nine-page treatise on his plans to help the disabled, including full funding for special education. Mr. McCain's 14 core campaign issues include the Second Amendment and the space program but not the disabled....

"Mr. McCain still has time to come around on these issues and offer specific remedies in the weeks ahead. Having a poster mom for families caring for a disabled child on the ticket is not enough -- particularly for aging seniors who can no longer care for middle-aged children. Friendship is nice, but families need a government willing to invest more in the future of children who require a little help if they are to live full and productive lives."

Disability Scoop

Special Ed News (Education Week)

Special Education Law